I know a man who delights in pointing his finger at his sparky little Jack Russell and exclaiming “Bang!” whereupon the terrier lies down and does a complete rollover. It is extremely cute and always gets a charmed laugh from onlookers, but what exactly is going on in that little Jack Russell brain? What connections is he making? Is he making any connections at all?

Trained dogs can easily distinguish dozens of different words of human speech. It is always a temptation to believe that they actually understand what these words mean, yet given the nature of their own communication system, the odds seem strongly against it. Dogs have come to associate certain sounds with certain actions, but those associations are often extremely dependent upon other contextual cues that we may not be aware of. One way to show this is to try giving a dog a familiar command over an intercom. Even a command that the dog is highly motivated to carry out is often ignored unless it is accompanied by some additional cues in our body language.

Indeed, for all of the many congruences that connect human and nonhuman animals, one of the great differences is the way we use language. Human infants, almost as soon as they begin to learn the names of things, take a manifest pleasure in using the name for its own sake. They will point to an object and say what it is - not because they want it, but for no other reason than to share the pleasure of calling the attention of another human mind to it.

Even language-trained animals, such as chimpanzees, that have been taught to create "sentences" with computer symbols or sign language expend something very close to 100 percent of their utterances on demands for food, toys, or attention. There is no evidence that they have an independent notion of the symbols as standing for concepts. They have, rather, learned to manipulate a series of symbols to get results.
Our dogs have certainly learned to look at us, or come, when we speak their name, but there is not a scrap of evidence that they grasp the notion that their name is their name, in the sense that it stands for or represents them. Given all that, however, it certainly seems odd that dogs can distinguish words in human language. Studies by Russian speech scientists found that dogs can readily be trained to distinguish the vowels a and i produced by an audio synthesizer; even when the base pitch of the vowels was changed, the dogs had no trouble telling the two apart.

Dogs may often be confused by substitutions of one consonant for another - try saying "Fly clown" instead of "Lie down," and your dog will probably react exactly the same. But the ability to distinguish vowels depends on rather precise analysis of the higher-pitched resonances that accompany their base pitch.

Dogs do not utter vowels themselves; why should they be able to tell them apart when we say them? The simple and general explanation for this happy circumstance is that ears are older than speech. Mammalian ears have been around for tens of millions of years, and the ears of all mammals have much in common. Human speech, however, has been around for only 100,000 years or so, and the human vocal tract is a unique and late development. Only humans possess the vocal apparatus needed to generate the sounds of speech.

We can believe that we control the dog’s conduct and behavior with commands which the dog has learned to understand, but the truth is, the non-verbal component of our communication carries more weight. Simple cause-and-effect basic training will instill in the dog certain behaviors like heel, sit and stay, etc., because the dog comes to understand not the words per se, but the owner’s desire that he comply with a particular response. The deep connections and long-lasting relationships which we create with our dogs are essentially symbiotic. We provide creature comforts and share our resources with the dog, while his innate intelligence tells him there’s great benefit to be had from continuing to interpret and fulfill our desires.
 

Agility Contacts | Agility Jumps | Agility Training Bookstore | Agility Tire Jumps | Chute & Barrel
Dog Beds| Dog Collar & Leash | Dog Crates & Carriers | Dog Nutrition | Dog Shows |Favorite Dog Breeds
Flyball Box| Flyball Training Videos | Holistic Pet Remedies | Make Your Own Agility Dog Jumps
Obedience Training for Your Breed | |Organic Dog Food | Teacup Tunnels |Tunnels & Chutes
Home | Contact Us | Shipping | About Us | Links | Site Map

Train your dog at home with equipment designed & built by seasoned Agility & Flyball competitors